What a roof from the 1930s and 1940s has usually been through
By now a house on this estate has had a lifetime of small repairs, and the covering on it may not be the one it started with.
A house on an estate begun just before the war has seen the best part of a century of weather, and over that time its roof will have been mended, patched and perhaps re-covered. We therefore start from the roof as it stands, not from an assumption about what builders used in the late 1930s. Climbing up and looking is the only reliable way to say what is on a given house.
The things that wear out are mostly the things you cannot see from the garden. Underlay, a membrane stretched across the rafters beneath the tiles' supporting laths (the battens), catches rain that gets past the covering. On an old roof it may be early felt that has gone brittle, torn at the eaves or never been laid at all. Battens can soften where water has reached them, and the nails that hold tiles or slates corrode until the covering starts to slide.
The signs inside the house are usually late. A damp patch on a ceiling means water has already crossed the underlay and the insulation, and the timbers above may have been wet for a long time. That is why a look from the loft hatch, with a lamp and a camera, is worth doing even when nothing seems wrong.
From there the decision is simple to describe and hard to make without evidence. A roof with sound tiles and a few failed details can be repaired. A roof with sound tiles over failed underlay can be stripped, re-felted and re-battened, and the good tiles laid back. A roof whose tiles have lost their surface needs a new covering. Our roof repairs and roof replacement pages set out how we draw that line.
A roof that has been re-covered before may also carry two layers of battens or a patched deck, and those are far easier to find on a first visit than halfway through a job.
Myth
If nothing is dripping through the ceiling, the roof is fine.
Fact
Slipped tiles, tired underlay and blocked gutters can wet the timbers for a long time before a stain shows indoors.



