Stone tiles: heavy, handsome and hard to replace
The abbey roof is a reminder of what happens when a stone covering is left too long.
When the abbey nave went onto the Heritage at Risk Register in 2022, the reason given was the state of its roofs. The nave is limestone ashlar, meaning squared and finely cut blocks, with a covering of stone tiles. It is a reminder that a stone roof can look settled for years and still be failing quietly underneath.
Stone tiles are laid in courses that get smaller towards the ridge, each one hung from a peg or nail driven through a hole at the top. Over time the peg rots or the nail corrodes, and the tile slides. Frost does the rest. Water gets into the bed of a layered stone, freezes, and splits the tile along its grain. A roofer who sees a few gaps in a slope should assume that the cause is the fixing, and that the tiles around the gap are close to going too.
Repairing a stone roof is a sorting job. We lift the courses, set the sound tiles aside by size, discard the split ones and rebuild from the eaves up, with the large tiles low and the small ones high. Where we need more stone, we source matching tiles in colour and thickness, reclaimed or new. A thin, regular tile in the wrong shade does more harm to the look of a stone roof than the original gap did.
Underneath, the timbers deserve attention. Stone is heavy, and the rafters and battens carry a great deal of weight for a very long time. An old, notched or twisted rafter will have an opinion on how much the roof can take. If a repair involves changing the covering, one 15 per cent heavier or more than the old one needs Building Regulations approval, and the change would need consent if the building is listed. We would rather keep a stone roof than replace it, and our approach to that choice is set out under pitched roofing.
Myth
A stone-tiled roof that has stood for centuries will keep standing without attention.
Fact
Pegs rot, frost splits the beds, and the weight of the stone tests the timbers, which is why even the abbey nave's roofs landed on a risk register.



