Victorian villas with slate roofs in a North Somerset town near the coast

Roofers in Winscombe

Winscombe lies on the western edge of the Mendip Hills, and by road it is 26.6 miles from central Bath, to the west. The village grew in two halves, one by the church and one by the old railway, and its roofs reflect both: older houses near St James's and the Victorian streets that followed the line.

Local roofs

Two halves of a village, one hill behind them

Winscombe sits on the western edge of the Mendip Hills, and the hill is always there behind it. The original settlement was up by the church. The railway station, when it arrived, stood in the Woodborough part of the parish, away from the old core, and the village grew in the direction of the line. That gives Winscombe two centres and two characters. Around the church the buildings are older. Around Woodborough they are the product of the railway age.

The Grade I listed Church of St James dates from the 15th century, with restoration and a new chancel in 1863. The railway came as the Cheddar Valley line of the Great Western Railway, opened in 1869, and the village grew in the 19th century with its arrival. The railway closed in 1963. Its route is now a public footpath and cycle track, and the former station site is the Millennium Green.

Seen from a ladder, that history doubles as a map of roof ages. Houses beside the church belong to the older settlement, and those that went up around Woodborough belong to the expansion that followed the line, so the two halves of the village call for different questions. A building of the 1870s or 1880s has a particular kind of timber, covering and chimney, and we read those before we plan anything. When we survey, we use what the building tells us, not what the village is supposed to be.

The survey itself is simple. You pay nothing for us to climb up and photograph your roof, and the price we then send in writing is final.

Council
North Somerset Council
From central Bath
26.6 road miles, west
Church
St James, 15th century, Grade I listed, new chancel 1863
Railway
Cheddar Valley line opened 1869, closed 1963
Former station
Now the Millennium Green, in Woodborough

What we find

Spent fixings, branch damage and old chimneys

Fixings at the end of their lifeRoofs laid when the railway arrived are now old enough for nails, pegs and battens to have given up. We look for slipped slates or tiles in lines along a course, which usually point to a failing fixing, not a failing covering.
Leaf and branch damage near treesFootpath and green-space edges mean mature trees close to some houses. We clear valleys and gutters, and look for tiles scraped by branches and moss lying in the shade of a canopy.
Chimneys on older housesBrick and stone stacks from the 19th century carry flashings and flaunching that have weathered for generations. We check the mortar, the lead and the stack's lean, and the soakers underneath if they can be reached.

Houses the railway built

When the Cheddar Valley line opened in 1869, Winscombe grew a second centre, and its roofs have reached the age where they ask for attention.

A railway changes where people build. Winscombe's station stood in Woodborough, away from the church, and the Victorian growth of the village followed the line. Wherever late 19th-century terraces, villas and cottages stand in those streets, their roofs are now well into old age.

The pattern on a roof of that date is familiar. The rafters are softwood, cut and fixed by hand. The battens are narrow and may have been nailed with iron, which rusts. The covering could be natural slate, clay tile or a later replacement, which is why we identify it before anything else. Underlay, if there is any, is usually a later addition. The roof was built to last, but the parts that join it together are the first to give out.

On a roof of this date we go looking for fixing failure first. Slates slip out of line, one at a time, and a pattern of gaps along a course tells us the nails have rusted, not that the slates themselves have gone. A tile with a broken nib (the small lug at its top edge that hooks over the batten) tells a similar story. Where the fixings are weak across the roof, the answer is usually to strip the covering, keep what is sound, fit new battens and underlay, and re-lay with stainless or copper nails.

That kind of work falls under roof replacement, and we explain the options. Re-roofing may fall inside Building Regulations. Whether a re-cover is notifiable depends on how much of the building and the roof it touches, and the thresholds are set out further down this page. When it is notifiable we deal with that paperwork, and extra insulation can be required under Part L.

Myth

A slipped slate means the whole roof is finished.

Fact

A single slipped slate is often a failed nail. If the rest are sound, re-fixing them on the same battens is a repair, not a re-roof.

Trees, the old track and roofs in shade

The old railway line is now a green corridor, and the trees along it are neighbours to many roofs.

The closure of the railway in 1963 left a strip of land that is now a footpath and cycle track, and the Millennium Green stands on the old station site. Green space brings trees, and trees affect roofs in four ways.

The first is debris. Leaves, twigs and seeds fall onto roofs and into gutters, and they do not stay where they land. They wash into valleys and hoppers, where they rot into a silt that holds water. A valley blocked with silt lets water back up under the slates, and the leak shows up well away from the cause. The second is shade. A roof that never sees the sun stays damp, and moss and lichen grow. The third is contact. Branches that touch a roof scrape the surface of tiles and slates, and a limb that comes down in a gale can break the covering. The fourth is roots, which can damage drains and, over time, the ground near a house.

We cannot deal with the trees themselves, which belong to their owners and may be protected. We can deal with what they do to the roof. Gutters are cleared and, where a leaf guard would help, we recommend one. Valleys are opened and lined again if the lead or the bedding has gone. Moss is removed where it is doing harm, by a gentle method that does not take the face off the tiles. On a soft or old covering, we may recommend leaving the moss and fixing the drainage instead.

Ask the council before you cut or fell any large tree near your house, because some are protected. Our roof cleaning page covers moss removal and the methods we prefer.

Clean or repair

Where the tiles under the moss are firm, a gentle clean plus better drainage will do; where they are flaking, put the money into the roof.

St James's and the older centre

A 15th-century church sets the tone for the buildings near it.

The Grade I listed Church of St James dates from the 15th century. Its chancel was added and the church restored in 1863. That makes it a building of several periods, with several roof structures, and the same is true of many older houses in the first part of the village. A roof there is often a patchwork of repairs: new battens in one place, old oak in another, a different covering on the extension.

A listed building is listed as a whole, roof included. For a listed house, North Somerset Council grants consent for changes as listed building consent, which is not an alternative name for planning permission, while St James, still holding services as an Anglican parish church, gets approval for roof work by diocesan faculty instead. We do not give legal advice, and we would not guess what the council will accept. What we can do is provide a clear description of the work: what is there, what has failed, what we propose to do and what materials we propose to use. A council officer can respond to that.

Church roofs and large older buildings have a particular weakness: lead. The gutters between roof slopes, behind parapets and under tower walls are lined in it, and sheet lead swells and shrinks as temperatures rise and fall. After many seasons it can split at its folds or slide slowly downhill. The splits let water into the walls, and it can run a long way before it shows. A leak in the nave can start from a gutter at the chancel.

Bats and nesting birds use old roofs. They are protected, and should evidence of either turn up, we pause the job and point you to Natural England before anything proceeds. That is rare in a domestic repair, but it does happen on older buildings.

We cover this kind of detail on the pitched roofing page.

Words you will hear

Chancel
The part of a church beyond the nave that holds the altar, usually roofed separately.
Nib
A little projection under the top of a clay tile that hangs it from the batten.
Batten
A slim strip of timber laid across the rafters, to which slates or tiles are hung.
Lead creep
Slow downhill movement of lead sheet caused by repeated heating and cooling.

Deciding between repair and re-roof

The question every older Winscombe roof eventually asks, and how to answer it with evidence.

Almost every owner of an older roof reaches the same question: patch it again, or replace it? The honest answer comes from the roof, not from us, and the way to get it is to look at three things.

The first is the covering. Is it sound? Slates and tiles can last a very long time, but only if they are not cracked, delaminating or flaking. Pick up one that has slipped and look at the back. A clean, flat surface suggests it is worth keeping. A layered, crumbling one does not. The second is the fixing. Are the nails rusted through? Is the batten rotten? If these have gone, the covering will go with them, whatever condition it is in. The third is the structure. Does the ridge dip? Do the rafters sag between the walls? A roof that is sound on top and soft underneath needs the underneath done first.

If the answer is repair, we say which parts, how many, and what the repair is expected to achieve. If it is replacement, we say what to keep. Reusing sound slates on new battens saves money and keeps the look of the roof. Where reuse is not possible we match the replacement to the original.

Regulation comes in at this point. According to the Planning Portal, a re-cover normally needs no approval while it touches under 25 per cent of the building as a whole and under 50 per cent of the roof itself. A heavier covering, at least 15 per cent above the old weight, needs approval plus a structural check, and a larger re-roof can trigger an insulation upgrade. Ask your building control body about your own case. On cost, the MyBuilder guide for 2026 says a new roof typically runs £5,000 to £12,000 in the UK. Nothing is fixed for your house until the survey is done. Our roof replacement page has the detail.

Map showing the location of Winscombe.

Nearby

Roofers near Winscombe

Roofing services in Winscombe

Local questions

Questions from both halves of Winscombe

My Winscombe house was built after the railway arrived. How old is its roof likely to be?

That depends on whether it has been re-covered, and the only way to tell is to look. Many houses of the railway period have had at least one repair, and some have been re-roofed. We check the battens, the nails and the underlay as well as the covering, because the age of the fixings matters more than the age of the slates. The survey report records what we find, with photographs.

Trees beside the old railway path overhang our roof. What should I do about the debris?

Clear the gutters and valleys after leaf fall, and have the roof looked at if moss builds up in the shade. The trees themselves belong to their owners and may be protected, so speak to the owner or the council before cutting anything. We can clear the drainage, repair damage the branches have done, and tell you whether a leaf guard would help in your case.

Can the roof of a Grade I church like St James's be repaired by a firm like yours?

Church roofs need specialist knowledge and the right permission, so a survey comes first, followed by talks with the diocese, whose faculty takes the place of council consent for a working Anglican church, and whoever advises the parish. We can survey, describe the defects and the repair method in writing, and carry out the work to the agreed scope. We do not guess at what the council will accept, and where bats or nesting birds are present we stop and take advice.

How can I tell whether a slipped slate is a repair or a sign the whole roof is going?

Look at the pattern and the slate. One or two slips on an otherwise even roof suggest a failed nail. Slips across several slopes, or slates that crumble in layers when lifted, point to the end of the covering. Photograph the roof from the ground with a zoom lens and send it to us if you like, but a proper answer needs someone on the roof.

Get your free survey

Get your free roof survey

Tell us what's happening and we'll call you back to arrange a visit. Prefer to talk? Call 01225 285181.

  • Photos of your own roof
  • A fixed price in writing
  • 10-year workmanship guarantee
Call Free survey